Skip to main content

Notifications

Microsoft Dynamics NAV forum
Suggested answer

"Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

editSubscribe (0) ShareShare
ReportReport
Posted on by 660

Hi all,

Please advise why this error will comes about. Is it not possible for value to be negative?

depreciation-value.JPG

Thank you!

  • Suggested answer
    Dirk Profile Picture
    Dirk on at
    RE: "Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

    On the Fixed Asset list or the card page,  click Ctrl & F7 to get the entries.

    Or go to the "Navigate" tab on the ribbon and click "Ledger Entries".

    I think it would be good to check if with the last depreciation the book value would turn negative.

    Maybe it is sufficient already to see the "Book Value" flow field on the Fixed Asset Card and in addition check whether a Salvage Value has been registered.

    In this case you should find a Fixed Asset Ledger Entry with "FA Posting Type" = "Salvage Value" for asset 210011

  • joshlabtech Profile Picture
    joshlabtech 660 on at
    RE: "Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

    May I ask where to locate the Fixed Asset Ledger Entries?

    What would you like to see?

    pastedimage1612430915247v1.png

  • Suggested answer
    Dirk Profile Picture
    Dirk on at
    RE: "Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

    Hi Josh,

    Thanks

    In order to understand the full history of this asset, is it possible to share all the "Fixed Asset Ledger Entries" which exist for this asset 210011?

    Which build of NAV 2018 is in use here?

    Thanks

     Dirk

  • joshlabtech Profile Picture
    joshlabtech 660 on at
    RE: "Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

    Hi all,

    Please see the image.

    User trying to run depreciation for this fixed asset code. 
    after she post this entry , this asset will fully depreciated

    chloe.png

  • Suggested answer
    Community Member Profile Picture
    Community Member Microsoft Employee on at
    RE: "Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

    Josh,

    Adding to Dirks reply... Are you trying to depreciate an Asset that is fully depreciated? Look at the Asset 210011 FA Ledger Entries to see if what is happening. Someone could have entered a Salvage value during the purchase process. Salvage value entry is available if you have selected the Acquisition Cost option in the FA Posting Type field. Typically, the salvage value must be entered as a negative amount. Entering a salvage value at the same time as the acquisition cost is especially important if you also select the Depr. Acquisition Cost check box. In this case, the depreciation basis will be acquisition cost minus salvage value. Look into this to see if this is the case.

    Hope this helps.

    Thanks,

    Steve

  • Suggested answer
    Dirk Profile Picture
    Dirk on at
    RE: "Book value must not be negative or less than Salvage value" in Navision 2018

    Hi,

    Can you share some more details?

    What do you want to achieve?

    Do you want to register Fixed Assets with negative book value?

    Or is this a message you get when you want to dispose an asset?

    Thanks

Helpful resources

Quick Links

Take the Community feedback survey!

Answer this brief 15-question survey about your Community experience…

Demystifying Copilot: Service Edition with Sundar Raghavan

Sundar answers more questions about Copilot for Service...

Dynamics 365 Business Central vs Finance and SCM

Take a look at the key differences between Business Central and…

Leaderboard

#1
Andre Arnaud de Calavon Profile Picture

Andre Arnaud de Cal... 283,375 Super User

#2
Martin Dráb Profile Picture

Martin Dráb 223,308 Super User

#3
nmaenpaa Profile Picture

nmaenpaa 101,140

Featured topics

Product updates

Dynamics 365 release plans