Hi, Ludwig,
Thanks for your response.
yes, I used this template. it works improperly for the cash account 110100 for budgeting.
My actual example is for period 1.1.2020..8.31.2020. Report date is 8.2020
Here are my budget entries
1. I wonder:
1.1 if it is correct to post the opening balance for the cash account for the beginning of 2020 year, as budget entry with 12/31/2019 with the budget Model FY 2020, see a picture above?
1.2 if it is correct to use the 'original budget' budget type for this entry? Or may be I need to use 'Carry froward budget' budget type for this budget entry, and it allows me to apply the attribute 'budget type' with this value ('Carry froward budget') for the specific column to get a specific value at the beginning of the reporting year.
2. When I apply column definitions as on your screenshot,( i just made the utility columns visible) , I get an improper value for the budgeting entries:
My purpose is to verify if I am able to get a correct value of cash accounts from the budget entries for the beginning of the year, and to show the proper value in ' Check Total - Cash at end of period' :
But I receive an improper data for the budget entries at the beginning of 2020. I need to have12000 usd there .
But I found another way how to get a proper value.
I changed the column definition:
I changed the row definition:
This set up allows me to take a value from dec 2019.
Now report looks correct.
but is it a proper approach for the one year budgeting model?
And if we use the budget model in MR that includes two years - submodels FY2020, FY2019, such an approach will not work .
Because we can not get a correct value for the beginning of second year using a current set up of column G.
But if we post the opening balance budget entry with 'Carry froward budget' budget type , we can add filter with this attribute to the the column G. And I think it should work properly.
What do you think ?
are approach #1,approach #2 correct?
or may be another proper approaches exist to get value at the beginning of the year for budget entry?
P.S
I have verified the second approach. it works.
i added and posted the budget entry with 'Carry froward budget' budget type.
And build report on the base of column definition with attribute Budget Type=[Carry-forward budget] for column G.