Hi Maria,
it should work, if the users have an exchange online account. I managed to do the test again and it works - see below

Now, if you are getting the error with the hiring manager do the following: remove the hiring manager and add him/her again. also, try with another employee from Azure Active Directory, with an exchange online account. it should work. it's a bug and it will be solved.
regards,
Nicu
read my blog: https://talent.asgcrm.com